Evaluation of Questionnaire and Testing

The main problems with the testing that we carried out was that we did not have a particularly large number of users (we had 7 respondants to the questionnaire) and these respondants were all from a similar background – 20-30 age range, mostly students who are “tech-savvy”. On the other hand, this group is likely to be an early adopter of the product. After reviewing and improving the design of the product, it would be a good idea to test it on a wider range of potential users to identify further problems; e.g. issues for users with visual impairments, elderly users or users with fat fingers.

 There was also some confusion from the test users who didn’t quite understand that this would be a touch-screen interface on a fridge – there were concerns that on small monitors the interface would take up too much of the screen, this wouldn’t be an issue as the prototype illustrates a piece of bespoke hardware running the software. It would have been beneficial if we had given a more in-depth introduction to the project and the exact nature of the prototype – it had been assumed that these test users would remember what we were talking about from a previous questionnaire.

Another issue was that we were unable to physically time people carrying out tasks. This was because the test users were not in the same physical location as us, as the prototype and questionnaire are both web-based. Also, the nature of our questions led to some respondants neglecting to give quantative or full answers. This made analysis more difficult and could be remedied by wording questions more carefully, adding addition questions specifically asking for certain data or only testing the prototype on users in the same physical location as us, so that we can resolve any confusion.

An additional effect of being in the same physical location as the testers, would be that the questionnaire could receive a different response when completed in the presence of human questioners, rather than a computer. Users are less likely to respond to “interviewer bias” when answering questions as all users will be asked the same questions in the same way. Additionally, users could be more honest when answering to a computer rather than a human, whose might respond negatively to a user’s opinion or disclose private information (http://www.surveysystem.com/sdesign.htm).

 Unfortunately, more detailed statistical analysis could not be carried out on our result set as the sample user group was too small for the results to be meaningful.

Using sound for navigation

From The Register and Tech Digest:

a_play_2.jpg

Miminalism is the key here – the Play has no screen and just a single joystick for control. It plays MP3, WMA and ASF files for up to 12 hours on a single charge of its built-in battery, has five equaliser pre-sets and can support up to four playlists or play through randomly in shuffle mode.

No screen and just a joystick control? How can you navigate through menus then?

The Asono Play uses different sounds to let you search through folders and choose different playing options. This really tackles the issue of lack of screen space investigated by Brewster and Cryer to an extreme level.

I’m not sure how easy this would be to use, but I guess once you got used to the different sounds and what they meant, it would be pretty cool.

Design and function

I’ve noticed lately that here and there, there are useful functional object being designed that look pretty good too.

 First up is the Radiator Heat Wave:

Compared to the white boring rectangular radiators you usually find in most homes, the Heat Wave radiator is a refreshing change. It looks really nice and it’s not obvious that it’s a radiator.

Next is the Titan refillable lipstick:

The big thing about this for me is that it’s refillable – it’s always struck me as a bit crazy that there is huge amounts of packaging for most products and then once you’re done with them you throw them away. Even though some make-up containers are recycleable, it’s not always obvious where you should take them to be recycled and so most people don’t bother. Other great features are that you can put it on a keyring with the rest of your keys – so no crazy rummaging like a baglady to find it, and it’s incredibley shiny.

 Shiny in the heatproof, crushproof metal kind of way. 😀

 Lastly is the Boynq Vase Speaker:

It’s a speaker that looks like a vase and connects to your laptop via usb (which also powers it). It looks nice, doesn’t take up too much space and would help solve the problem of most laptop speakers being kind of tinny.

Web enabled fridge

But technology had run amok at the LG Electronics booth, where its $10,000 Web-enabled refrigerator lets you watch TV, download music from the Internet, leave messages, send and read e-mail, keep track of food supplies, order groceries online, conduct videoconferences, make two-way video phone calls and take still photographs (that’s me, smiling and waving in the photo at left). Aiieee! Stop!

Frigidaire is refining its prototype Electrolux “screen fridge,” which provides Internet access, a place to leave family messages, a way to order groceries online and a built-in video camera for personal messaging, among other things.

“The refrigerator is the center of the kitchen, and we want it to be the center of the home,” Mitchell said, a one-stop control center for the household. And there is something to be said for making maximum use of the one family appliance that is always on.

Being able to conduct video conferences and make two way video phone calls from your fridge seems a bit over the top, as does turning it into a giant camera. On the other hand, integrating tv, music and email as well as keeping track of food and being able to order it all seem fairly useful – many kitchens have radios and televisions in them already.

http://www.sptimes.com/News/051901/Homeandgarden/Gourmet_gear__Look_wh.shtml

Blogger and bad HCI?

One thing I noticed when looking at the list of blog groups for those taking the HCI module this year, is the number of people who have got the address of their blog wrong.

If you sign up for a blog that uses the blogger software, you have to sign up on Blogger.com. So, logically, your blog would be hosted there right? Wrong. Blogs that you sign up for at Blogger.com are actually hosted on the Blogspot.com domain. This accounts for the wrong addresses given for a number of the blogs and is an understandable mistake. Perhaps Blogger should reconsider where users sign up for their blogs, or make it more clear where the site will be hosted.

Tech Banzai – Expensive Ovens, Cheap Meals

Tech Banzai – Expensive Ovens, Cheap Meals

I’m not sure what use an internet controllable oven would be, though the idea of being able to see inside your fridge (rather than oven as jokingly mentioned at the end of the entry) while not in your house could be useful if you intend to pop to the shops after work or lectures and have internet access. Or at least have some link from the fridge to a mobile device that could provide you with a shopping list when you’re at the supermarket.

Of course, this only works if you’re not the kind of person who leaves their shopping lists/mobiles at home by mistake when going shopping.

Initial questionnaire

We conducted an initial survey to see what people thought about the idea of an intelligent fridge and what kind of features they would like to see in it.

So far, the main complaints that those who responded to the questionnaire had were that their fridge was not big enough (or had space for a certain shape of product) and that their food tended to freeze. These two points can sometimes be related – if the fridge is overstocked with food, items can freeze because there is not enough empty space to allow cold air in the fridge to circulate. Another complaint was that it was sometimes difficult to tell what was in the fridge – especially a problem for very full fridges, and things that were forgotten about because they were not easy to see often went “off”.

More on this questionnaire later.

Tangible interface for home entertainment systems

Towards a Playful User Interface for Home Entertainment Systems

This would be useful for people like my dad who has trouble reading the small print in tv guides and the tiny labels on remote control buttons and as it seems to be fairly intuitive to use, if my parents did have something like this for their tv, especially if it could pick up the channel the vcr plays on, there would be fewer phone calls asking me “how do I get the video to work?”.

Another interesting point, considering Monday’s lecture on questionnaires, was the various questionnaires used in the testing of the interface and the answers given to the questions.